DSCR Prepayment Penalties Explained, David Mahoney, NEXA Mortgage

DSCR Prepayment Penalties Explained: 5-4-3 and More

November 02, 2026•5 min read

Almost every DSCR loan comes with a choice you do not see on a conventional loan: the prepayment penalty. Pick the right one and you get a lower rate for a penalty you will never pay. Pick the wrong one and selling or refinancing early gets expensive. Here is how DSCR prepayment penalties work, the common structures, and the state rules that change the options.

What a prepayment penalty is

A prepayment penalty is a fee charged if you pay off a large part of the loan early, during a set period after closing. On DSCR loans, a penalty is typically triggered when you pay off more than 20% of the principal balance in a year. Selling the property or refinancing the loan during the penalty period is the usual trigger.

Lenders price DSCR loans assuming they will collect interest for a while. A penalty protects that, so a longer penalty usually gets you a lower rate. No penalty, or a short one, usually costs more in rate.

The common structures

5-year step-down (5-4-3-2-1)

  • Year 1: 5% of the balance paid off
  • Year 2: 4%
  • Year 3: 3%
  • Year 4: 2%
  • Year 5: 1%
  • After year 5: none

The longest common option and usually the best pricing.

3-year step-down (5-4-3)

  • Year 1: 5%
  • Year 2: 4%
  • Year 3: 3%
  • After year 3: none

The most popular middle ground.

5% fixed

A flat 5% for a set term, often 3 years. Some lenders offer it as the alternative to a step-down.

Six months of interest

Some lenders offer a penalty equal to six months of interest on 80% of the original loan amount, for a set term.

3-2-1 and shorter terms

Some lenders offer a 3-2-1 step-down or 1 to 2 year terms. For example, one Texas investor David worked with chose a 2-year fixed 5% penalty on one property and a 3-year 5-4-3 on another, to match each property's plan.

No prepayment penalty

Available on many programs at a higher rate. Worth it if you are likely to sell or refinance soon.

How to choose

Ask one question: what is the realistic chance you sell or refinance this property during the penalty period?

  • Holding long term: a 5-year or 3-year step-down usually saves you more in rate than you would ever pay in penalty.
  • Might refinance if rates drop: a 3-year penalty is a common compromise. Run the numbers: the penalty in year 2 or 3 against the rate savings from a new loan.
  • Flipping to a buyer soon or unsure: a short penalty or none.

David prices each option side by side, so you see the rate and the payment for every structure before you choose. Changes to the penalty after you lock are priced off the rate stack from your original lock date, not the current market.

State rules that change your options

Prepayment penalties are restricted in some states. These rules decide what is even on the table.

New Jersey: close in an LLC

In New Jersey, a DSCR loan must close in an LLC to have a prepayment penalty. If you close in your own name, plan on a loan without a penalty, which usually means a higher rate. If you are buying in New Jersey, set up the LLC before you lock.

Ohio: limits on 1 to 2 unit properties

Ohio law (Ohio Revised Code section 1343.011) limits prepayment penalties on 1 to 2 unit properties: - At or below the state threshold ($116,356 for 2026), no prepayment penalty is allowed. - Above the threshold, the penalty is capped at 1% (structured 1-1-1) for up to 5 years. - Standard penalties such as a 5-4-3 are available on 3 to 4 unit properties.

That is why an Ohio duplex DSCR loan, or an Ohio DSCR second mortgage on a smaller property, often has no penalty at all, with the pricing to match.

Minnesota: 3 years max

On files David has priced in Minnesota, lenders confirmed a 5-year penalty is not allowed. A 3-year penalty is the longest available.

Other states

Rules change and lenders apply their own overlays. Your state is one of the first things David checks.

Prepayment penalties on DSCR seconds

If you add a DSCR second mortgage behind your first, the second can carry its own penalty, subject to the same state rules. Read more about second mortgages.

A quick example

Say you take a 3-year 5-4-3 penalty and sell in year 2 with $295,000 still owed. The year 2 penalty is 4%. If your note applies it to the full payoff, the penalty is $11,800. Some notes apply it only to the amount above the 20% you are allowed to prepay each year, which makes it smaller. Your loan documents spell out the exact calculation, so ask David to walk through the number before you choose.

These numbers are an illustration only.

Fees

You pay $0 processing, $0 admin, $0 broker, and $0 origination fees. Lender underwriting and standard third-party costs (appraisal, title) still apply.

NEXA Mortgage is the largest mortgage company in the country. NEXA funds the majority of loans in-house, giving us direct control over pricing, underwriting, and your timeline, plus access to 350+ lenders to make sure you get the strongest terms available.

Get the options priced

Apply online or text David at (747) 361-0852. Email: [email protected]. You will see each penalty option with its rate before you pick.

FAQ

What is a 5-4-3 prepayment penalty?

A 3-year step-down: 5% in year 1, 4% in year 2, and 3% in year 3, charged on a large early payoff. No penalty after year 3.

When is a DSCR prepayment penalty triggered?

Typically when more than 20% of the principal balance is paid off in a year during the penalty period, such as by selling or refinancing.

Can I get a DSCR loan with no prepayment penalty?

Yes, on many programs, usually at a higher rate.

Do New Jersey DSCR loans have prepayment penalties?

Only if the loan closes in an LLC.

Are prepayment penalties allowed in Ohio?

On 1 to 2 unit properties, none at or below the 2026 threshold of $116,356, and a 1% cap for up to 5 years above it. Standard penalties apply on 3 to 4 units.

Have a deal to run? Apply online or text David at (747) 361-0852. Email: [email protected].

Business-purpose loans for non-owner-occupied investment property only. The borrower must certify business purpose and non-owner occupancy. Prepayment penalties may apply and vary by state. David Mahoney, Loan Officer, NMLS #2685840. NEXA Mortgage LLC, NMLS #1660690. Serving all 50 states; not all products are available in all states. Licensing: NMLS Consumer Access. This is not a commitment to lend. All loans are subject to credit approval, underwriting, property eligibility, and lender guidelines. Programs and terms vary and may change without notice. Equal Housing Opportunity.

blog author avatar

David Mahoney

Senior Mortgage Loan Originator at NEXA Mortgage, NMLS #2685840. NEXA Mortgage NMLS #1660690.

Back to Blog